Prolific writer Mike Bartlett is the most impressive penman to have emerged in British theatre in the past decade. The trouble is that his work is so uneven. Although he wrote the amazingly imaginative play, Earthquakes In London, and the Shakespearean West End hit, King Charles III, he has also been responsible for the preposterous improbabilities of the second series of the BBC’s Doctor Foster. Is his new play, Albion,  a three-hour state-of-the-nation epic billed by the Almeida Theatre as the story of one woman searching “for seeds of hope,” a triumph or another trawl through improbability?

Albion begins with Audrey, played with indefatigable energy by Victoria Hamilton, in the garden of her deceased uncle’s family home, deep in the English countryside. She has bought the property, which boasts a historic 1920s garden, now much overgrown, which a First World War veteran once formed into a pastoral paradise fit for heroes. Given that the garden is called Albion, and is divided into themed areas, it is not hard to see that Bartlett has created a powerfully metaphoric play, one with shades of Tom Stoppard’s Arcadia, Charlotte Jones’s Humble Boy and Jez Butterworth’s Jerusalem.

Audrey, who is the wealthy fiftysomething head of a design company, is taking time off work to pursue her pet project: the restoration of Albion gardens. This brings her into conflict with friends and family. Although Paul, her second husband, supports her emotionally, Zara, her 23-year-old metropolitan daughter from her first marriage, has doubts about village life. While Anna, the partner of her dead son, killed by a roadside bomb in Iraq or Afghanistan, only wants to honor his memory. The garden becomes a battleground as the competing wants of these three women clash repeatedly.

Soon a fourth woman, Katherine, a famous novelist and a very old friend of Audrey’s, arrives, and Zara, who is a Cambridge graduate with aspirations to write, is attracted to her. As you’d expect, class is an issue so all of these privileged folk must also interact with others from less exalted backgrounds. There’s Matthew, an old gardener, and his wife Cheryl, Gabriel the 19-year-old neighbor, Krystyna the Polish cleaner, and Edward, who owns the house next door. As well as family tensions, there are social concerns: Edward wants the grounds to be open to the local community while Audrey wants them for her private use; the Polish cleaner does a better job than the English cleaner; the working-class writer is patronized by his social superiors.

Over about nine months, the project of restoring Albion gardens rises and falls, while family conflicts sharpen: where will Audrey decide to scatter the ashes of her soldier son and will Anna, his lover, or Zara, his sister, have any say in the matter? In one of the play’s four acts, the characters hold a 1920s fancy dress party, emphasizing the fantasy aspect of trying to recreate a lost world, and the inevitable shades of Downton Abbey haunt this country house family play. There are passionate passages about Brexit, about the economy, and about creativity. A nearby rock music festival, commercial rather than nostalgic, threatens the peace; female friendship is anatomised.

Spending most of the play center stage, Hamilton’s Audrey is a wonderfully theatrical monster. Imperious, opinionated, selfish and offhand, she strides about, firing off cutting comments and giving orders, a Thatcherite Tory in, during one fiery scene, a bright red dress. As a matriarch, she believes that she knows best what her 23-year-old daughter wants, but does she know the first thing about either Zara or about her closest friend? A passionate nostalgic, she truly believes that she can restore the past in all its English glory. But theatre is a liberal space, and we know that no one can put the clock back.

As a picture of a nation divided, the drama is both acute and a bit banal. Audrey clearly represents the kind of Toryism that believes in the trickle-down effect, whereby the rich enjoy the services of servants and then pat themselves on the back for giving poorer people employment. Her husband Paul is almost comically lazy, a man who just basks in his privileged inactivity. Zara has the callow yet ambitious steel of the upper-middle-class young, her every speech suggesting a sense of entitlement, while Katherine represents the bohemian Guardian-reading liberal classes (here caricatured as believing that a fascist takeover of Britain is possible). Of course, the conflict between the hardworking, if humorless, Pole and the old slow working-class locals indicate a concern with the tensions behind Brexit, but Bartlett never resolves any of these conflicts. Most of the time, it feels like the playwright’s sympathies lie with Audrey rather than with those who suffer from her actions: her “seeds of hope” can only yield selfish fruit.

Albion is a tragi-comedy which is bright with insights and one-liners. While not entirely free of preposterous moments, with the storytelling occasionally getting bogged down in exposition and clunky declarations, the play is breathtaking in its ambition and at its best achieves a neat balance between believable family drama and a more metaphoric state-of-the-nation resonance. It’s enjoyable, humane, and highly symbolic. The silliest moments are the endings of Act Two when Anna rubs soil into her crotch, and of Act Four when (but I can’t say because it would be a spoiler).

Along with Hamilton’s sterling performance, Rupert Goold’s whole cast acquit themselves well. As well as doing some heroic gardening during the scene changes on Miriam Buether’s green and pleasant set, they provide a series of supporting cameos. Helen Schlesinger (Katherine), Vinette Robinson (Anna) and Charlotte Hope (Zara) are particularly convincing, while Edyta Budnik (Krystyna), Luke Thallon (Gabriel) and Nicholas Rowe (Paul) are often a delight to watch. Christopher Fairbank and Margot Leicester give the old gardener and his wife a deservedly sympathetic air. Albion is a very long evening, but a heartfelt and satisfying one.

Albion is at the Almeida Theatre until 24 November.

This post appeared on Aleks Sierz on October 19, 2017, and has been reposted with permission.

This post was written by the author in their personal capacity.The opinions expressed in this article are the author’s own and do not reflect the view of The Theatre Times, their staff or collaborators.

This post was written by Aleks Sierz.

The views expressed here belong to the author and do not necessarily reflect our views and opinions.